The SPAB is often asked about historic brickwork over our telephone advice line. Brick can be one of the most durable building materials, as testified by the survival of notable Roman examples. Not infrequently, however, poor repairs, a lack of maintenance and inappropriate alterations lead to trouble. Douglas Kent, SPAB Technical Secretary, explains why.
Q. What should I do with the deteriorating brickwork on my historic building?
A. It is essential to establish the cause of deterioration and keep any remedial work to a minimum. This will help prevent recurrence of the problem and, by restricting the loss of historic fabric, retain the authenticity of the building.
Sometimes, it may be best to do nothing, ie leave the brickwork alone. Where this is not an option, some form of conservative repair can frequently be undertaken. Only in exceptional circumstances will brickwork need to be taken down and rebuilt.
Where work to historic brickwork is being considered, the SPAB may be able to suggest the names of suitable contractors and professionals or advise on appropriate courses.
Q. What causes brickwork to deteriorate?
A. Accelerated decay is commonly associated with poor repairs, neglected maintenance or unsuitable alterations. Deficiencies in design, materials and workmanship may also play a role.Such factors can result in:
Q. What might repair entail?
A. Selective work to the joints and/or bricks. In some cases, only minor re-pointing of eroded joints will be required after, say, the rectification of a leaking rainwater fitting. With buildings pre-dating c1914, soft lime mortar and not hard cement should be used to minimise evaporation through the bricks and consequent deterioration of their faces.
The bricks themselves can often be carefully removed and then reversed to hide the decay. Tile stitching may be an appropriate repair for cracks in historic brickwork, particularly where horizontal joints are no longer in line. Providing the joints between tiles are kept fine and care is exercised, the repair will gradually weather in.
Coloured mortar (‘plastic’ repairs) may be used and to build up decayed brick faces but skill is required to achieve a good long-term colour match. Thin brick slips have been used as an alterative but possess an inherent structural weakness.
Q. If necessary, how might I replace bricks?
A. Only bricks that are severely damaged should be cut out and replaced. Exact replication is very difficult, but there are a number of good suppliers producing new hand-made bricks at reasonable prices. Replacement bricks should match the existing ones as closely as possible in size, colour, texture and durability. They should be laid in the same way, ie with the same bond. It is better to leave replacement bricks to blend in naturally over time than to try and tone them down.
The SPAB is cautious about the use of second-hand bricks. In addition to philosophical considerations, there are technical reasons: salvaged bricks may be underfired and unsuitable for external work, or are sometimes damaged, stained or painted. Occasionally, brick may be re-used from another part of the same building - but then, only with considerable discretion.
Q. Should I paint or treat bricks to protect them?
A. No, this is generally inadvisable. Paints and colourless water-repellent solutions can cause additional deterioration by trapping moisture in the brickwork. Also, moisture can be forced greater distances to escape, thereby increasing the mobilisation of damaging soluble salts.
Notwithstanding this, where a render has previously been stripped from brickwork it can, on occasions, be prudent to replace it to provide protection against the weather. The application of a new render or lead cladding to previously unprotected brickwork can also be sensible in certain circumstances, for example to protect the inside face of a parapet wall suffering from saturation.
Internally, the plastering or limewashing of exposed brickwork might be justified, for instance where inappropriate sand-blasting has caused ‘dusting’. Listed building consent may be required for these works.
Q. Should I clean historic brickwork?
A. Cleaning is justified in certain circumstances, but in many cases will do more harm than good. It risks damaging the brickwork, can remove a building’s sense of history, and may bring only short-term benefits. Cleaning can be appropriate, however, when there is a need - for example, to remove inappropriate paint finishes, graffiti or very heavy soiling.
The method(s) of cleaning must be carefully chosen in consultation with a specialist. Abrasive techniques will probably remove the protective fireskins from the bricks, leaving the softer inner parts vulnerable to decay. Water-based methods can cause unsightly efflorescence (white deposits) or damp penetration. Chemical cleaning can sometimes produce satisfactory results, but inadequate washing off may cause staining. An on-site trial should always be conducted first.