Inappropriate replacement windows blight old buildings. They are the home ‘improvement’ likely to cause most harm to a property’s value. However, it is a common misconception that old windows are incapable of being upgraded, as Douglas Kent, SPAB Technical Secretary, explains.
Q.How feasible is it to upgrade rather than replace old timber windows?
A. Windows in the majority of old buildings can be upgraded for better draughtproofing, thermal insulation, noise control or security, though total compliance with modern standards may not necessarily be advisable. Upgrading is nearly always preferable to replacement, and may entail some associated repair (see SPAB News, Vol 24, No 2, p50). A careful, practical approach is needed, and, where work is planned, the SPAB may be able to suggest names of specialists in your area.
Q. Might ‘Part L’ of the Building Regulations require me to replace an old timber window?
A. Not with a historic building. "Historic" in the context of Part L includes buildings that are listed or in a conservation area, and, importantly, buildings that are unlisted but have "historic and architectural features for the preservation of which a sound case can be made". Whilst Part L seeks to improve the energy performance of all buildings, including existing ones when altered, extended or subject to change of use, it states that with historic properties a "reasonable" approach must be taken that balances the conservation of fuel and power with the conservation of the fabric.
If upgrading existing windows is not practicable, benign improvements might be made elsewhere (for example, fitting thermostatic controls to radiators). Unlike replacement, window repair is not subject to Part L. Similar requirements apply in Scotland under Part J.
Q. Do I simply have to put up with draughts through old timber windows?
A. No. Although old buildings that "breathe" need greater ventilation to remove moisture than new ones, air leakage through windows is often excessive. Furthermore, owners commonly mention thermal radiation through glazing as the reason for replacing windows whereas, in fact, the major source of heat loss is air infiltration around casement edges. Elimination of draughts should, therefore, be the immediate consideration.
First, service, ease and adjust the opening casements. If air leakage between the frame and casements is still a problem, this might be remedied by draughtproofing the windows and, if present, shutters too. The various forms can be either a gap filler (mastic or foam) or oversized fitting (tube, brush or fin). To reduce condensation, allow for additional ventilation near sources of moisture, or only partially seal windows. Heavy curtains, insulated blinds, reinstated shutters and secondary glazing may be used additionally, or as alternative methods.
Q. How can I improve the thermal insulation of old windows?
A. As well as draughtproofing, secondary glazing may be a good way to reduce the thermal transmittance (U-value) of old windows. It comprises an extra layer of (ideally non-reflective) glass that fits to the inside of the existing window and, if well designed, is unobtrusive. It can be removed when not wanted in the summer. For thermal insulation, the optimum air gap between panes is 20mm. A little ventilation should be maintained through the outer window to prevent condensation on the inner face.
Because windows in old buildings are typically small relative to wall areas, the amount of heat saved means double-glazing is rarely cost-effective. Double-glazed units result in loss of historic fabric, are obtrusive and suffer misting as seals eventually fail.
Q. Can I reduce noise through old windows?
A. Secondary glazing combined with draughtproofing is suggested, reducing low and high frequency noise respectively. The same principles apply with secondary glazing as when used for improving thermal efficiency - except there must be a wide air space between panes (minimum 150mm) and their thickness should differ by at least 30 per cent. Fitting secondary glazing in just some windows (perhaps only those alongside a busy road) can offer better acoustics internally than upgrading them all.
Q. Can the security of old windows be improved?
A. Measures include supplementing existing ironmongery with new fittings and, where they exist, closing and barring shutters at night.
Did you find this article useful? Why not join the SPAB and learn more about historic buildings from our quarterly publication for members, The SPAB Magazine, or make a donation to support our work in protecting historic and fragile buildings.
We hope this information has been helpful. We are changing the way we present our advice and guidance soon, as part of a bigger project to update our website. If you'd like to help us make our advice work better and you've got a spare 10 minutes, please consider taking this short test. We'd be very grateful for your feedback.
Information on upgrading is available from English Heritage (including a guidance note on the application of Part L, free by phoning 0870 333 1181 and quoting code 50675).
Historic Scotland also produces various leaflets.